The latest episode of Disney+’s Star Wars: The Acolyte has ignited a firestorm of debate amongst Star Wars fans. According to Screenrant, the controversy centers on a surprise cameo appearance by a major character, Jedi Master Ki-Adi-Mundi, who was played by Silas Carson (Phantom Thread) in the first three movies within the franchise. This has caused fans to dispute whether the series follows the timeline within the franchise or if it breaks the canon.

According to Screenrant, an X post by the user Annabelle_dawn explains that the character’s birth was never revealed and that his cameo makes perfect sense; however, another fan by the name of RON1NSenju disputed this, saying, “It’s confirmed in the credits that was a young Ki-Adi-Mundi. The guy who in episode one said Sith hasn’t been seen for a MILLENIA… Disney DON’T KNOW STAR WARS!!!”.

Some fans have found the plot point in the episode implausible, while others view it as an intriguing opportunity. The series has the opportunity to explore on how the Sith will operate from the shadow, potentially revealing weaknesses within the Jedi Order itself. According to Screenrant, the series showrunner, Leslye Headland (Russian Doll), has stated, “As such, including him in the story and exploring how The Acolyte‘s Sith-centric events can take place without him being aware of the dark siders’ involvement is a logical move.” The Acolyte delves into the resurgence of a Sith threat, a plot point some find implausible given Ki-Adi-Mundi’s apparent lack of awareness in the prequels.

Ultimately, The Acolyte’s adherence to canon will likely continue to be a point of contention as the series progresses. Whether the show can reconcile fan expectations with creative license remains to be seen. but they undeniably highlight the enduring power of this beloved sci-fi saga. Four episodes are currently streaming on Disney+, with the fifth one being released next Tuesday.