The latest episode of The White Lotus, directed and written by Mike White, maintains the show’s signature blend of dark humor and social commentary, though it doesn’t quite capture the intensity or intrigue of its previous seasons.

The episode opens with Katie and Jaclyn gossiping behind Laurie’s back. Through their conversation, we learn that Laurie has recently gone through a divorce and is struggling with her troubled daughter. While the episode continues with the familiar dynamics and tone of its predecessors, it often feels like it’s trying too hard, almost leaning on edgy moments for the sake of making a point rather than offering anything truly new. Though the sharp dialogue and biting observations are reminiscent of earlier seasons, they feel less effective here, as if the show is treading familiar ground without advancing much.

Chelsea’s friendship with Chloe also unfolds, revealing Chloe’s connection to Tanya’s ex-husband, Greg, who is now going by the name Gary. Meanwhile, Rick reluctantly opens up to Amrita, and while this moment of vulnerability adds depth to his character, it doesn’t quite achieve the emotional impact of earlier character arcs in the show.

The episode takes a darker turn when a robbery occurs at the resort’s boutique, echoing a similar event from Season 1, albeit much earlier in this season than in the past. As the characters’ personal and professional lives become increasingly entangled, The White Lotus continues to captivate some viewers with its signature blend of satire and drama. Yet, the question remains: is the series still as compelling as it once was?

While The White Lotus has always excelled at exploring the darker side of its characters— insufferable, often detestable individuals—the latest season doesn’t quite hit the mark. The characters here seem more one-dimensional, offering less in terms of standout performances. Earlier seasons succeeded by making even the most unlikable characters compelling to watch, but this season struggles to evoke the same level of engagement. Perhaps some have grown tired of the premise, but it feels as though the material has become weaker and less inspired than before.

Take, for example, the two women, Katie and Jaclyn, who spend much of the episode gossiping and belittling each other. Their constant back-and-forth feels more grating than entertaining this time around. Even Walton Goggins, an actor who usually stands out no matter the role, feels underused and lackluster. His portrayal, while true to form in being an asshole, lacks the sharp wit or complexity that typically makes his characters interesting. What went wrong?

It’s still early in the season, so who’s to say the momentum won’t change? But for now, this episode’s characters lack the depth and nuance that made earlier seasons so memorable. There’s little emotional connection with any of them, and the constant bickering and passive-aggressive behavior leave little room for growth or empathy.

Rating: 6/10